The Scottie Scheffler-Tiger Woods Comparison: A Different Kind of Greatness originally appeared on Athlon Sports.
On Aug. 28, 1996, Tiger Woods made his professional debut at the Greater Milwaukee Open with his famous "Hello World" interview. That same day, I was unpacking my first apartment in Orlando, having moved from upstate New York to start my golf business career and pursue PGA membership.
Advertisement
Watching Woods' interview while unpacking, I thought: This kid sure is getting a lot of hype. We'll see how this pans out.
Three decades later, we know exactly how Woods turned out. For those who might care, I've reached my goals too. Ask anyone who knows me — I'm a huge Woods fan. Yes, his off-course failures disappointed me. His injuries have been heartbreaking to watch. But his 2019 Masters comeback gave me chills.
I always believed we'd never see another Woods, and that remains true.
Advertisement
However, what we're seeing with Scottie Scheffler has the makings of greatness in an entirely different way.
Scottie Scheffler places his ball on the 10th green while wearing Tiger Woods Nike shoes during a practice round for the Masters on April 3, 2023, in Augusta, Georgia.
The Inevitable Question
The Scheffler-Woods comparisons are impossible to ignore, and they're fair game. Woods and Jack Nicklaus are the measuring sticks for statistics and wins. Woods may be the best when he was clicking in the early 2000s. Nicklaus was history's most dominant major champion.
Scheffler has the chance to be a hybrid of both men we consider the GOATs of golf.
Advertisement
When Scheffler won the Open at Royal Portrush this past weekend, securing his fourth major, the Woods comparisons reached fever pitch.
The statistics were striking: Exactly 1,197 days passed between each player's first and fourth major wins. Scheffler became only the second player to win the Open while world No. 1 — Woods did it three times.
Scheffler's response was characteristically humble.
"I still think they're a bit silly," he said of the comparisons. "Tiger won 15 majors. This is my fourth. I just got one-fourth of the way there. Tiger stands alone in golf."
Advertisement
The Numbers Don't Lie
The statistical parallels can't be denied and shouldn't, for that matter. Scheffler has converted his last 10 54-hole leads into victories, a nod to Woods' legendary closing ability. Woods' record of 37 consecutive conversions might be untouchable, but Scheffler's streak demonstrates the same ruthless efficiency.
I love what Rory McIlroy said recently about Scheffler's achievements: "You could argue there's only two or three players in history who've been on a run like Scottie's for the past 24 to 36 months."
Advertisement
That is a really insightful perspective from someone who is conceivably in this conversation too.
Scheffler's four majors were all won by three-plus shots — making him the only golfer in the modern era to achieve this with his first four majors. He's one U.S. Open win away from completing the career Grand Slam. Add 13 PGA Tour victories and Olympic gold from Paris in 2024, and he's setting the standard every other professional measures against.
A Different Kind of Dominance
What makes Scheffler's dominance fascinating is how different it feels from Woods' peak. Where Woods brought predatory intensity — fist pumps and roars heard across fairways — Scheffler operates with mechanical calmness that's equally intimidating.
Advertisement
Jordan Spieth, once compared to Woods after winning three majors, highlighted this difference: "He doesn't care to be a superstar. He's not transcending the game like Tiger did. The difference in personality from any other superstar you've seen in the modern era — maybe in any sport — I don't think anybody is like him."
This emotional restraint was evident during Scheffler's Open victory. While Woods might have fed off crowd energy, Scheffler methodically dismantled the field with eerie composure. One rare emotional moment: a vigorous fist pump after a crucial par-saving putt on the sixth green.
Shane Lowry offered perspective on why Scheffler doesn't always get deserved recognition.
Advertisement
"If Scottie's feet stayed stable and his swing looked like Adam Scott's, we'd be talking about him in the same words as Tiger Woods," Lowry said. "Because it doesn't look perfect, we don't talk about him like that."
The Technical Evolution
Scheffler's unorthodox technique proves there's no single path to greatness. His footwork can look clumsy, his swing lacks textbook beauty, yet results speak volumes.
More importantly, Scheffler improves weaknesses like Woods did. In late 2023, he sought putting guru Phil Kenyon to address his weakest skill. Switching to a claw grip for shorter putts transformed him from the PGA Tour's worst putter to the most reliable.